Aaron Hohlbein was named third team All-American in 2006 after being named a preseason third team All-American. A three-time Big Ten All-Tournament team selection, Hohlbein earned first team All-Big Ten honors in 2005 and 2006, as well as second team All-Big Ten honors in 2003 and 2004. As a freshman he was also named to the Big Ten All-Freshman team. Hohlbein received the Big Ten Sportsmanship Award in 2005 and was named Academic All-Big Ten in 2006.

Josh Provan was selected third team All-American in 1996 after being named to the All-Midwest Region team and first team Big Ten that same year. A three-time Academic All-Big Ten selection, Provan was named to CoSida Academic All-Region second team in 1995.

Mike Gentile, a three-time first team All-Big Ten honoree, was selected third team All-American in 1995 after helping lead the Badgers to the 1995 NCAA Men's Soccer Championship. Gentile was named to the All-Midwest Region team in 1993 and 1995. A three-time first team All-Big Ten selection, Gentile wrapped up his career at the UW with 16 goals and 21 assists for 53 points.

Scott Lamphear, one of just two first-team All-Americans in program history, helped lead the Badgers to the 1995 NCAA Men's Soccer Championship. A three-time first-team All-Big Ten selection (1993-95), Lamphear was co-captain of the 1995 NCAA Championship team. He was also a three-time Academic All-Big Ten choice and a two-time first-team CoSIDA Academic All-Region honoree who earned the 1996 Big Ten Medal of Honor. Lamphear was inducted into the UW Hall of Fame in 2011.

Tim Deck was selected first-team All-American in 1993, becoming the first player in program history to earn the selection. Deck currently holds UW school records for single-season goals against average (0.49), career goals against average (0.87), single-season shutouts (13.5) and career shutouts (28.5). He is tied for second all-time with 38 career wins. Deck was named to the All-Midwest Region team in 1993 and earned two All-Big Ten first team selections (1992 & 1993), along with being named second team All-Big Ten in 1991.

Gerald Averill, the current UW career record holder with 40 wins, was selected third team All-American in 1986. Wisconsin's first All-American selection, Averill was also a member of the All-Midwest Region team in 1985 and 1986, named Academic All-Big Ten in 1985 and 1986 and selected to the CoSida Academic All-Region first team in 1985 and 1986. Averill finished his career with 40 wins, 299 saves, 24 shutouts and 1.13 goals against average.