With national signing day for football coming up on Wednesday, this is the time of year a lot of folks get wrapped in recruiting rankings, "five-star" athletes and "winning" signing day. I thought it would be a good idea to go back and look at the Badgers' signing day classes in recent history and see how they fared. I left out last year's class because obviously the jury is still out on most of the players.
I don't want this taken as an indictment of recruiting rankings. According to Rivals.com, Alabama has had the No. 1 class in the country three of the last four years. And I heard they were pretty good this season. So there is some correlation between success on the recruiting trail and succeeding on the field. However, both Illinois and Minnesota were ranked higher than UW in 2008, 2009 and 2010. Their combined record over the last three seasons was 29-46 (.387). Wisconsin was 32-8 (.800).
From 2007-10, Wisconsin signed 86 players to National Letters of Intent. Sixty-four of those players (74.4 percent) are either still on the Badgers' roster or finished their careers at UW. A recent story came out that Auburn has only retained 57 percent of its signees from 2009 and 2010 (both classes ranked in the top 20 in the country by Rivals). UW has 39 of its 45 signees (86.7 percent) still on the roster over that span.
On the field, these classes have helped UW win back-to-back Big Ten titles, play in consecutive Rose Bowls and become one of just six teams in the country to win at least 10 games in each of the last three seasons.
Below are some facts and figures for the Badgers' classes in question:
2007 - 17 players signed - Ranked 34th nationally and 7th in the Big Ten by Rivals - Produced 11 starters - 10 players finished their careers as Badgers - 7 earned All-Big Ten honors and 1 All-American - Notable signees: RB John Clay (4 stars), S Aaron Henry (3 stars), OL Josh Oglesby (5 stars), WR Nick Toon (4 stars) 2008 - 24 players signed - Ranked 41st nationally and 6th in the Big Ten by Rivals - Produced 14 starters (includes 2 walk-ons) - 15 players finished their careers as Badgers or are still on the roster - 6 earned All-Big Ten honors (includes 1 walk-on) and 2 All-Americans - Notable signees: CB Antonio Fenelus (2 stars), OL Peter Konz (4 stars), LB Mike Taylor (2 stars), OL Kevin Zeitler (3 stars) - Notable walk-ons: FB Bradie Ewing (2 stars), OL Ricky Wagner (not rated) 2009 - 21 players signed - Ranked 43rd nationally and 8th in the Big Ten by Rivals - Produced 9 starters (includes 2 walk-ons) - 17 players are still on the roster - 5 earned All-Big Ten honors (includes 1 walk-on) and 2 All-Americans - Notable signees: RB Montee Ball (4 stars), LB Chris Borland (3 stars), OL Travis Frederick (3 stars), TE Jacob Pedersen (2 stars) - Notable walk-ons: Ethan Hemer (not rated), Jared Abbrederis (not rated) 2010 - 24 players signed - Not ranked in Rivals top 50, 11th in the Big Ten - 22 players are still on the roster - Notable signees: DT Beau Allen (3 stars), OL Rob Havenstein (3 stars), RB James White (3 stars), WR Manasseh Garner (3 stars) - Notable walk-ons: K Kyle French (not rated), LB Marcus Trotter (not rated)
As the teams make their final preparations for the Saturday's Senior Bowl, the Badgers who are participating in the game are still turning heads. However, inclement weather forced the North squad to "practice" inside a ballroom in the Mobile Convention Center.
Russell Wilson and the other North Team QBs have impressed the Minnesota Vikings coach staff they have been working with all week (Minneapolis Star-Tribune).
Pro Football Weekly's two reporters both couldn't help but notice Wilson during Wednesday's practice ("I wasn't watching the North quarterbacks closely this morning, but Wisconsin's Russell Wilson nonetheless caught my eye").
Even though he's not at the Senior Bowl (probably because he left as a junior), C Peter Konz shows up on Pro Football Weekly's Mock draft 1.0 at No. 18 to San Diego ("Konz has the strength and power to make an immediate impact and fortify the Chargers' interior").
The Senior Bowl will start at 3 p.m. CT with coverage beginning on NFL Network at 2:30 p.m.
Some observations and links from Tuesday morning's North team practice at the 2012 Senior Bowl in Mobile, Ala.:
QB Russell Wilson was again largely discussed on the NFL Network coverage. Badger head coach Bret Bielema called in to talk about his quarterback with Paul Burmeister and Mike Mayock (VIDEO).
The beat writer for the Houston Texans (Badgers south?) from the Houston Chronicle weighed in with his thoughts on Wilson ("Wilson has a nice, over-the-top delivery and keeps high during his backpedal") and Kevin Zeitler ("I was very excited to see Kevin Zeitler because he's such a powerful and technically sound run blocker and he didn't disappoint in the scrimmage phase").
Pro Football Weekly also briefly touched on Wilson ("Wilson was very impressive. He was accurate, consistent and had the best zip on his ball of the three quarterbacks"). They also checked in later on video breaking down Wilson's day.
Zeitler, who moved over and played a little center during practice, impressed Tom Melton ("As I said in my preview of the Senior Bowl I think that Kevin Zeitler is the top senior offensive guard and I still believe that").
Tony Softli, who covers the Rams, also had good things to say about Zeitler ("Tough and aggressive lineman. Is not the best athlete of the bunch, but he has that over-achiever attitude with skill set to develop at the next level. I like this young man.") and Wilson ("When it's all said and done, this quarterback might be the best at the 2012 Senior Bowl. Play-maker!").
Punter Brad Nortman also has been turning some heads. After Monday's practice, SI.com's Tony Pauline said, "Brad Nortman (P/Wisconsin) was kicking moon shots all afternoon. His punts were consistently flying 55-to-60 yards with great hang time."
SB Nation also chimed in following Tuesday's practice, "Wisconsin punter Brad Nortman boomed his kicks and routinely got quite a bit of hang time, garnering him some attention from a few scouts after practice."
Practice continues today, televised live at 10 a.m. CT on NFL Network.
Three former Badger defensive players took part in all-star games last weekend, with Aaron Henry playing in the East-West Shrine game, Patrick Butrym in the NFLPA Collegiate All-Star game and Antonio Fenelus in the Battle of Florida.
Fenelus, the only one of the three Badgers with an official invitation to the NFL Scouting Combine, was on the losing end of a 51-3 score at FAU Stadium in Boca Raton, Fla. He did account for one of the South Team's highlights, recording an interception. Fenelus also added two tackles and pass breakup.
Henry was voted the captain of the victorious West team in the East-West Shrine game in St. Petersburg, Fla. Defensive stats were hard to come by but The Naples Daily News caught up with Henry before the game.
Butrym played in the NFLPA Collegiate Bowl, but information and stats on the game are scarce.
In contrast to that, the Senior Bowl is like the Super Bowl of college all-star games. Practices are televised, reporters are numerous and scouts fill the stands. Five Badgers are participating this week, including QB Russell Wilson, FB Bradie Ewing, OL Kevin Zeitler, P Brad Nortman and LS Kyle Wojta. WR Nick Toon was invited to the Senior Bowl but is sitting out due to a foot injury.
As is usually the case, the QBs garnered a lot of attention, especially on NFL Network's coverage of practice (VIDEO). The New York Times blog also broke down the QBs: "Wilson is an exceptional athlete and it showed on the first day of practice. He didn't start particularly well, but as the session progressed he was the most impressive quarterback in the first practice of the week."
And the Charlotte Observer also caught up with Wilson to discuss the one thing he has no control over, his height.
In the early going, Zeitler is the highest rated draft prospect among the former Badgers. He impressed a number of folks, including the web site NEPatriotsDraft.com: "Kevin Zeitler was a stud all day long, I didn't see him get beat at all and when I did watch him he dominated Alameda Ta'amu, knocking his helmet off of him. He is feisty and a battler."
NFLmocks.com also praised Zeitler: "I find it funny that everyone talks about DeCastro but no one talked about Zeitler. DeCastro might be better but I am not willing to admit that yet. Zeitler dominated in both run blocking and pass blocking in college and faced much stiffer competition. He fared well against Devon Still and Jerel Worthy who are both thought to be 1rst Round talents. With a week in front of scouts many might start wondering if Zeitler is DeCastro's equal."
The strongest endorsement came from DraftCountdown.com: "Wisconsin OG Kevin Zeitler was incredible at right guard. Zeitler wowed onlookers and showed a real nasty streak in the 1-on-1 drills. Alameda Ta'amu is just one of the guys who struggled to make anything happen against the Badger blocker. On the day Zeitler was only beat once and looked every bit the part of a first rounder."
Coverage of the Senior Bowl practices continue on Wednesday and Thursday at 10 a.m. CT on NFL Network. There is also a daily recap show on Wednesday and Thursday on NFL Network at 9:30 p.m. CT. The Senior Bowl game is then televised live on NFL Network at 3 p.m. CT.
One year after having five players taken in the 2011 NFL Draft, including two in the first round, a number of former Badgers are embarking on a three-month job interview that will culminate in late April. The 2012 draft will be held April 26-28 and, for a number of familiar names to UW fans, the "Path to the Draft" has already started.
Some of the seniors from the 2011 Wisconsin squad that have NFL scouts talking are QB Russell Wilson, OL Kevin Zeitler, WR Nick Toon, FB Bradie Ewing and FS Aaron Henry. With junior center Peter Konz forgoing his senior season to put his name into the draft, there's a good chance that as many as seven or eight Badgers will hear their name called in late April.
As the former UW players train for the draft, they are spread all over the country, in Florida, Arizona, California and even Milwaukee and Madison. Over the course of the next three weeks, we will try to catch up with as many of them as possible to keep tabs on their progress.
There are a number of important dates between now and late April. Some of them are below:
NFL Draft (New York City) April 26-28 NFL Network and ESPN
This weekend, senior defensive captains Henry and DT Patrick Butrym have the chance to show off for scouts. Henry will be playing in the East-West Shrine Game while Butrym takes part in the NFLPA Collegiate All-Star Game.
Those two games are a prelude to the Senior Bowl. A school-record six Badgers will play in that game and take part in a week's worth of practices in front of NFL scouts. The UW players include Ewing, P Brad Nortman, Toon, Wilson, LS Kyle Wojta and Zeitler.
The "main event" of the NFL draft prep is the 2012 NFL Scouting Combine on Feb. 22-28 in Indianapolis. The NFL released its initial invite list, which does not include underclassmen and is not a final list. Among the Badgers heading to Indy are CB Antonio Fenelus, Nortman, OL Josh Oglesby, Toon and Wilson. More UW players, including Konz, should be added to the invite list later.
If nothing else, this should be an interesting offseason for the Wisconsin seniors. And for Badger fans, if you don't get NFL Network, you should probably find a way to watch it because UW should have a strong presence there for the next couple of months.
For much of the country, Thanksgiving means spending time with family, watching NFL games on TV and eating copious amounts of food. For a number of Wisconsin student-athletes, coaches and staff members, Thanksgiving bore a striking resemblance to "Thursday" on their daily schedules.
That's not to say they didn't celebrate the holiday, just that it may have been in a slightly different fashion than most people are used to.
For the second year in a row, the Badger football team is hosting a football game on Thanksgiving weekend with enormous ramifications on the Big Ten race. Last year, UW pounded Northwestern on its way to earning a share of the Big Ten title. This Saturday, Wisconsin and Penn State meet to determine the Leaders Division representative in the inaugural Big Ten Football Championship game.
Because of that, the Badgers had a regular practice on Thursday, although a little earlier in the day. The early start time allowed those players who live locally (more than 50 players on the roster from Wisconsin) to get home for a quick Thanksgiving meal. For those not so fortunate or those choosing to spend it with their other "family," the team dined at Samba, an all-you-can-eat Brazilian steakhouse in downtown Madison. Hopefully they ordered some extra beef for the evening.
As you can see from the photos, the men's basketball team also ate as a team today. The Badgers are in Hoffman Estates, Ill., getting ready to play Bradley on Friday in the Chicago Invitational Challenge. After practicing at the Sears Centre, UW headed back to the team hotel for a little turkey and stuffing. It may not be as exotic as the Thanksgiving meal we had in South Padre Island in 2006 but I'm sure there was plenty of good food for the guys tonight.
The women's basketball team is also on the road, albeit a little further from Madison than Chicago. After playing at BYU on Wednesday, the Badgers are in Boulder, Colo., as they prepare to take on Montana State on Friday in the Colorado Omni Classic. They also practiced earlier in the day and had a team "feast" at the hotel. As you can see from the photo below, it looks like a good time was had by all. In addition to the video above, check out some other WBB players talking about what they're thankful for.
Both UW hockey teams are at home this weekend, as is the volleyball team. Like the football team, the men's hockey team let players who live close enough go home for a quick meal after practice. Some guys tagged along to eat with their buddies while the rest of the squad ate as a team at the Coliseum.
With six UW teams in action this weekend, their Thanksgiving traditions may have been put on hold. However, Badger fans everywhere are hoping to be thankful for some victories once the weekend comes to a close.
On Oct. 16, 2010, the Badgers rolled up 184 rushing yards against a rush defense ranked fourth in the country, toppling No. 1 Ohio State, 31-18. Montee Ball never left the sideline.
In the two weeks prior, a loss at Michigan State and a home win against Minnesota, Ball carried a total of five times for 16 yards.
Heading into a road game with No. 12 Iowa, Ball's last significant action had come in the fourth quarter of a 70-3 win over Austin Peay. But in the second quarter of the Iowa game, with the Badgers trailing 6-3, freshman sensation James White went down with a knee injury.
On his first play from scrimmage, a 3rd-and-12 from the Iowa 21-yard line, Ball took a shovel pass from Scott Tolzien and scampered 14 yards for a key first down. On the next play, Tolzien hit Bradie Ewing for a TD to put the Badgers back on top.
Starter John Clay continued to get most of the reps at tailback but Ball was called upon at key times. None bigger than the Badgers' final drive. He caught a fourth-down pass to help keep the drive alive, but his biggest play was an 8-yard run that punctuated the drive and gave the Badgers the lead. Seemingly carrying the entire Iowa defense on his back, Ball has first hit around the 5-yard line but just kept churning and reaching, finally stretching his arm across the goal line with 1:06 left in the game.
Since that point, Ball has been on one of the most remarkable runs (pun not intended) in Badger history. He ran for at least 127 yards in each of the final five games of 2010, including 132 against the No. 3 rush defense in the country, TCU, in the Rose Bowl. He also scored 14 TDs in those five games.
In 2011, Ball has reached an even higher standard. He leads the NCAA with 30 total TDs. He is just the fifth player in FBS history to score at least 30 touchdowns in a season and has a shot to reach the NCAA record of 39 set by Barry Sanders in 1988. Ball has already broken the Wisconsin and Big Ten records for touchdowns in a season and is averaging a touchdown every 8.0 times he touches the ball.
Ball is averaging 133.3 yards per game and ranks second in the country with 1,466 yards on the ground (just two yards behind the NCAA leader). He is even better during Big Ten play, averaging 158.0 yards per game. That's the best average for any RB in one of the six BCS conferences during league play.
Instead of "MoneyBall" Montee's nickname should probably be "Mr. November." In the last three weeks Ball has run for 613 yards, an average of 204.3 per game. In four November games last season, he averaged 161.3 yards.
Ball has also raised his game against the top competition. In three games against teams ranked among the top 16 in the country in total defense (Michigan State, Ohio State and Illinois), he has averaged 141.3 rushing yards, 159.0 all-purpose yards and scored seven touchdowns (four rushing, three receiving).
An added dimension this season for Ball has been his ability to catch the ball out of the backfield. He ranks fourth on UW with 233 receiving yards and has caught five TD passes. His total of 1,699 rushing and receiving yards ranks third in the country among RBs.
As the season winds down and the national and conference award races heat up, the names that continually pop up on the national scene are Ball, Richardson (Alabama), James (Oregon) and Wilson (Virginia Tech). Within the Big Ten, Nebraska's Rex Burkhead and Iowa's Marcus Coker are having great years as well.
And with the Heisman Trophy race wide open, "MoneyBall" seems to be playing his way into that conversation as well.
Average Rank of Defenses Faced (FBS Only - Total Defense)
-- Matt Barkley, USC
Games left: #63 Oregon, #87 UCLA
-- Russell Wilson, Wisconsin
Games left: #9 Illinois, #8 Penn State
-- Kellen Moore, Boise State
Games left: #105 Wyoming, #117 New Mexico
-- Landry Jones, Oklahoma
Games left: #110 Baylor, #91 Iowa State, #101 Oklahoma State
-- Andrew Luck, Stanford
Games left: #16 California, #36 Notre Dame
-- Brandon Weeden, Oklahoma State
Games left: #91 Iowa State, #46 Oklahoma
-- Robert Griffin III, Baylor
Games left: #46 Oklahoma, #113 Texas Tech, #14 Texas
-- Case Keenum, Houston
Games left: #33 SMU and #79 Tulsa
It started with a bang. On national TV, the opening night of the college football season, Russell Wilson burst onto the national scene by doing just about everything right in his Badger debut, a 51-17 win over UNLV. The buzz was instantaneous.
He showed up on the front pages of ESPN.com, SI.com and Yahoo.com, among others. Wilson and the Badgers breezed through the rest of the non-conference schedule, UW's offense putting up huge numbers with Wilson directing it all.
At the beginning of October, the Badgers were 4-0, ranked seventh in the country and Wilson and his unique story were making national headlines. The eyes of the college football world descended upon Madison that first weekend of October for No. 8 Nebraska's first-ever Big Ten game. ESPN College GameDay was there and the game was on primetime on ABC.
Wilson responded with probably his best game up to that point, starting with his opening pass when he sidestepped an unblocked Jared Crick and uncorked a 21-yard completion to Jared Abbrederis to convert a third down. He finished the game 14-of-20 for 255 yards and two TDs while also running for 32 yards and another score as the Badgers rolled to a 48-17 win.
The next week, Wilson was at or near the top of every Heisman Watch. RussellManiaXVI was launched and picking up steam. A bye week was followed by a rout of Indiana, in which Wilson CAUGHT a TD pass that made all the highlight shows. Things were good, especially with two primetime showcase games on the horizon.
But RussellMania hit an unexpected bump. Things started out well enough, as the Badgers dominated the first quarter and jumped out to 14-0 lead at Michigan State. A disastrous second quarter put the Badgers in a hole, one that Wilson nearly pulled them out of. Down 31-17 with less than 10 minutes left in the game, he ran for a TD and threw for another as UW tied the game with 1:26 left. I think we all remember what happened next.
The next week, at Ohio State, a familiar script played out. Wisconsin jumped out to a first-half lead, Ohio State dominated the third quarter and Wilson led a furious comeback. This time, he threw two TD passes and added a 2-point conversion in the final four minutes to give the Badgers a 3-point lead. Once again, I think we all know how the game ended.
His fourth quarter numbers in those two games: 10-of-19 for 173 yards, three TDs and one interception (pass efficiency of 170.7). That pass efficiency would rank fifth in the country (ahead of Luck, Weeden, Jones and Barkley). Add to that a rushing TD and a completed two-point conversion pass.
As you can guess, the two losses not only dropped the Badgers down the national polls but also derailed RussellMania. Fair or not, many of the national awards, chief among them the Heisman Trophy, have a lot to do with which teams win games. I've been around long enough to understand that. I also know that if we had held on to win the Ohio State game, Wilson would have been hailed for leading an unbelievable comeback and been talked about with all the other frontrunners.
And that's the reason for this blog. I realize that this year's quarterback class is one of the best in recent years. Each week it seems a new QB pushes himself into the national spotlight with an outstanding performance.
After 11 weeks, though, it seems as though a group has separated itself at the top. The QBs who are most often discussed are Wilson, Andrew Luck (Stanford), Kellen Moore (Boise State), Landry Jones (Oklahoma), Brandon Weeden (Oklahoma State), Case Keenum (Houston), Matt Barkley (USC) and Robert Griffin III (Baylor). It's a terrific QB class and is seems as though each on has "won" the Heisman at some point or another this year.
The thing that I think separates Wilson from the others is his efficiency. He ranks 81st in the country in pass attempts. While the other seven QBs mentioned above all throw the ball at least 31 times a game, Wilson is averaging 21.8 pass attempts per game. So in order to be successful, the emphasis at Wisconsin is placed on efficiency at the QB position. And Wilson has taken the word to a whole different level this season.
He leads the country and is on pace to break the NCAA record in pass efficiency. With yesterday's performance at Minnesota, that number is at an other-worldly 201.6. He is also on pace to break the NCAA records for yards per attempt and yards per play. His yards per completion are also the best in the nation and nearly a full yard better than Keenum, who is second. Wilson is on pace to become only the fourth QB in Big Ten history to throw at least 30 TD passes in a season despite only attempting 21.8 passes a game.
The quality of defenses Russell has faced also measures up favorably against the other QBs. Wisconsin has played five teams that are ranked among the top 70 in total defense. That's compared to just one for Baylor, two for Oklahoma State, Oklahoma and Houston (none higher than 57), and three for Boise State and Stanford (none ranked higher than 49). USC and Barkley have also faced five teams among the top 70.
There's still two games left and for the Badgers and that means facing two defenses ranked in the national top 10. My hope is that the folks who vote for the national awards take all the numbers (wins and losses included) into consideration and let the season play out before leaving Wilson off any ballot he may be deserving of.
By Brian Lucas on November 9, 2011 2:47 PM
It started innocently enough. Sundays are when I update the game notes for the following week. The biggest story this week is obviously the series with Minnesota and the history of the "Battle for Paul Bunyan's Axe." The most basic of the information about the series is the won-loss record of the teams in the 120 games since 1890.
With the knowledge that there are sometimes discrepancies between the record books of two schools, I decided to take a peek at Minnesota's records to make sure they matched ours. According to both, the Golden Gophers led the series 59-53-8. That was a relief.
Upon closer inspection, however, I found that there were some differences in the records in games played in Madison and in Minneapolis. The UW record book (pg. 226 - since corrected) had the Badgers at 30-21-6 in games played in Madison while Minnesota's book (pg. 144) had it as 32-22-6. In games played in Minneapolis, our book said Minnesota led 38-23-2 while UM had it as 37-20-2.
Now that it is over, I'm glad we were able to participate. If you had asked my thoughts in the middle of August, I may have been singing a different tune. And especially after I saw an advance copy of the show yesterday, I think it's one of the coolest things I've been a part of in my 13 years at UW.
Wednesday at 6 p.m. CT, Depth Chart: Wisconsin debuts on ESPN. It offers fans an inside look at the Badgers' Fall Camp, focusing on the QB position. With the focus on the QBs, obviously a lot of the show revolves around Russell Wilson.
It offers a great look at Wilson's progress at learning the offense and fitting in with his new teammates. It also touches on the injury to Jon Budmayr and how that impacts the No. 2 QB, in this case, redshirt freshman Joe Brennan.
ESPN has released a number of trailers for the show, which we have below. If you can't catch it tonight on ESPN, it will re-air tonight at 10 p.m. CT on ESPNU, Thursday at 5 a.m. CT on ESPNU and Friday at 9 a.m. on ESPNU. So set your DVRs!