| 2011-12 |
| James Oldeschulte, Men’s Rowing |
| Sara Watermolen, Women’s Rowing |
| 2010-11 |
| Brett Valentyn |
| Carla Pentimone |
| 2009-10 |
| Max Wilson, Men’s Soccer |
| Kaela Erickson, Women’s Lightweight Rowing |
| 2008-09 |
| Kristi Johnson, Women’s Rowing |
| Daniel Stevens, Men’s Rowing |
| 2007-08 |
| Sara Bauer, Women’s Hockey |
| Adam Barhamand, Men’s Rowing |
| 2006-07 |
| Kathleen Holyoda, Women’s Rowing |
| Nathan Brown, Men’s Track and Field |
| 2005-06 |
| Lexi Goldin , Women’s Tennis |
| Nathan Brown, Men’s Track and Field |
| 2004-05 |
| Yael Peled, Women’s Track |
| Leah Gordon, Women’s Rowing |
| Michael Triebwasser, Men’s Rowing |
| 2003-04 |
| Julie Stefan, Women’s Track |
| Matthew Gajda, Football |
| 2002-03 |
| Jodi Zilinski, Women’s Soccer |
| Ryan Kipp, Men’s Rowing |
| 2001-02 |
| Stacy Sawtelle, Women’s Track |
| Nicholas Kitowski, Men’s Rowing |
| 2000-01 |
| Allison Blomquist, Women’s Golf |
| Robert Croll, Men’s Tennis |
| 1999-2000 |
| Laura Martin, Women’s Track and Cross Country |
| Eric Leicht, Men’s Track |
| 1998-99 |
| Shannon Brown, Women’s Soccer |
| Mark Danahy, Men’s Rowing |
| 1997-98 |
| Carin Bouchard, Softball |
| Alastair Steel, Men’s Soccer |
| 1996-97 |
| Julie Johnson, Women’s Soccer |
| Ryan Kehoe, Men’s Soccer |
| 1995-96 |
| Gina Utrie, Women’s Rowing |
